—

Huckabee retreats on birthright citizenship

By Stephen Dinan

The Washington Times
January 9, 2008

Mike Huckabee yesterday contradicted his own top immigration surrogate,
announcing he will not support a constitutional amendment to end
birthright citizenship for children born in the United States to
illegal aliens.

It was a stark reversal after The Washington Times reported that
James Gilchrist, founder of the Minuteman Project, said Mr. Huckabee
promised to pursue an amendment to the Constitution. In an article in
yesterday’s editions, Mr. Huckabee’s spokeswoman did not challenge the
former Arkansas governor’s statements to Mr. Gilchrist and said the two
men shared the same goals on immigration.

But by yesterday afternoon, Mr. Huckabee had backed away from that position.

“I do not support an amendment to the Constitution that would
prevent children born in the U.S. to illegal aliens from automatically
becoming American citizens. I have no intention of supporting a
constitutional amendment to deny birthright citizenship,” Mr. Huckabee
said in a statement posted on his campaign Web site.

The Times reported that Mr. Gilchrist, in a half-hour conversation
while campaigning with Mr. Huckabee last week in Iowa, pinned down the
Republican presidential candidate on various immigration stances,
including how he would address what most legal scholars see as the 14th
Amendment’s guarantee of citizenship to any person born in the United
States, except for diplomatic situations.

Mr. Gilchrist said Mr. Huckabee promised to bring a test case to
the Supreme Court to challenge the matter, and also would press
Congress to pass an amendment to the Constitution.

In an interview with CNN, the candidate said his campaign was not
contacted about the story: “It was disappointing the reporter who filed
the report never bothered to contact our campaign,” he said.

But Mr. Huckabee’s spokeswoman, Kirsten Fedewa, did talk to The
Times for the article. She did not challenge any of Mr. Gilchrist’s
statements at the time, and was quoted as saying Mr. Huckabee and Mr.
Gilchrist were “united by a mutual desire to end illegal immigration
and are political allies toward that end.”

Topics: illegal immigration, Mike Huckabee, campaign, Jim Gilchrist, Minuteman, liars, elections, issues, President, no trust

In a statement to The Times yesterday evening, Mr. Huckabee acknowledged his campaign was asked about the story.

“I was asked to respond to questions by The Washington Times about my
position regarding presidential pardons for imprisoned U.S. Border
Patrol agents Ignacio Ramos and Jose Compean and about personal e-mail
correspondence by one of my supporters,” Mr. Huckabee said. “We
responded to those questions.

“If the Supreme Court chooses to review lower-court decisions
regarding the 14th Amendment, that is their prerogative, but my
priorities for constitutional amendments are to protect human life and
traditional marriage,” he said in the statement.

Mr. Huckabee also said on CNN that he hasn’t given much thought to
the issue of birthright citizenship. But he previously had taken a
position in an interview with The Times on his campaign bus in Iowa in
August.

“I would support changing that. I think there is reason to revisit
that, just because a person, through sheer chance of geography,
happened to be physically here at the point of birth, doesn’t
necessarily constitute citizenship,” he said at the time, according to
the audiotape of the interview. “I think that’s a very reasonable thing
to do, to revisit that.”

Mr. Gilchrist did not respond to repeated phone calls and e-mails
yesterday asking about the discrepancy, but in a 42-minute telephone
call Sunday he told The Times that Mr. Huckabee promised him these
things in their half-hour private conversation.

“I read back my notes to him twice and I told him I did not want to
put words in his mouth,” he said. “The guy looked me right in the eye.”

Mr. Gilchrist issued a press release from the Minuteman Project
laying out Mr. Huckabee’s positions. That release was provided to the
Huckabee campaign.

Yesterday, Mr. Gilchrist’s Web site, www.jimgilchrist.com href=”http://www.jimgilchrist.com,/”>,
still included a photo from his meeting with Mr. Huckabee in Iowa, and
still said Mr. Huckabee promised to pursue a Supreme Court decision and
a constitutional amendment.

Rep. Ron Paul, the libertarian-leaning Republican candidate, has
introduced a constitutional amendment to end birthright citizenship.